Dining Review: Matilda’s

Craig OuthierNovember 10, 2026
Share This
https://www.phoenixmag.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/PHM1226EB03-1280x853.jpg

Devon McConville serves up a Ro-Ro sensation with her winsome all-day café.  

by Craig Outhier | Photography by Angelina Aragon

It’s patio season again in the Valley – and thus an ideal time to visit Matilda’s in the Roosevelt Historical District. 

Set on a pleasant, unhurried street shaded by elm and ash, in the same impeccably restored 112-year-old bungalow that once housed Garden Bar, this “all-day café” from coffee-cart priestess Devon McConville opened last winter and became an instant favorite of the young-mom set, known to spread picnic blankets over the front lawn and chit-chat over lattes while the kids frolick nearby. Until summer kicked in, anyway.

Well, fall is here, and the Matilda’s lawn and patio is a Monet painting once more. It’s not quite like anything else in Phoenix. 

The food is almost as idyllic. Head chef Matt Celaya, known for his pop-up events with the Más Amable culinary collective, has created one of the Valley’s most engaging and versatile menus. Three menus, more accurately. The day begins in fast-casual fashion with a balanced selection of breakfast dishes (served until 11 a.m.)  headlined by a princely egg-and-cheese sandwich swiped with a hot gust of preserved Calabrian chile on a poppy seed milk bun. Pair it with one of McConville’s exquisite, mixology-inspired seasonal lattes, offered in espresso or matcha form. The Baklava, sweetened with honey and aromatized with orange blossom water, is a scrumptious, pistachio-dusted eye-opener from the current fall menu. 

pork sandwich
pork sandwich

Breakfast gives way to a sandwich-centric lunch menu (served until 4 p.m.), including a saucy, Yucatán-inspired braised pork sammy done in a chile-tamarind adobo, with charred pineapple and crisp, bitter radish for balance. I loved it with the Photo Finish from Matilda’s craft cocktail menu, combining mezcal and coconut tea with passionfruit, honey, papaya and lime for a refreshing, tiki-adjacent sip.

McConville gamely gives the kitchen a one-hour break until full-service dinner kicks in (5 p.m. to close). From the six-item appetizer menu, don’t miss the bruschetta of creamy gigante beans, sweet piquillo pepper, fennel slaw and orange zest on a toasted baguette. It’s a symphony of bright Mediterranean flavor and perhaps my favorite new dish this year. Entrées are a slightly mixed bag. Done in a mild peperonata sauce (red bell peppers, onion, olive oil) over rich mascarpone polenta, the Café Chicken was a table-pleaser, but tagliarini (ribbon egg pasta) was a one-note garlic bomb.

Celaya’s recipes shift seasonally, so keep an eye on the horizon for some fresh culinary swells. And don’t forget your picnic blanket.

Bread pudding French toast
Bread pudding French toast
Café Chicken
Café Chicken
Matilda’s 

Cuisine: Modern-American

Contact: 822 N. Sixth Ave., Phoenix, 602-962-1956, matildasallday.com

Hours: M 8 a.m.-4 p.m., W 8 a.m.-9 p.m., F-Sa 8 a.m.-10 p.m., Su 8 a.m.-4 p.m. 

Highlights: Breakfast Sammy ($16); braised pork sandwich ($19); Baklava latte ($5.50-$7.50); bean toast ($17); Café Chicken ($28)