First Dish: Nanaya Japanese Kitchen

Craig OuthierJanuary 19, 2021
Share This

Set in the storied strip-mall spot formerly occupied by Crudo and, ages ago, an Italian restaurant with mob connections, Nanaya Japanese Kitchen opened in October to minimal fanfare – a “stealth opening,” one might say. This was dictated both by form (the speakeasy-ish, around-the-back location is easy to miss from the street) and function (the restaurant is evidently serving as a “test kitchen” for a future project in Old Town Scottsdale). When the tavern-style Japanese eatery finally did arouse my attention, a visit was all but mandatory.

3603 E Indian School Rd., Phoenix, 623-432-9114,

The Scene
Owned by Eddie Chow and Akira Nakasu – expat restaurateurs making their debut in the States after running a smattering of restaurants in East Asia – Nanaya takes the form of a classic Japanese izakaya, i.e. a casual tavern-style restaurant, where weary salarimen could pop in for a drink after work and dine on a limited but well-curated menu of Japanese standards. There’s a stylish, lounge-y bar area (essentially untouched since Crudo owner Cullen Campbell vacated the space in 2019), a spacious dining room (not yet operational when we visited in mid-January) and a wee but extremely pleasant patio (for dine-in and COVID-leery customers).

The Highlights
At first blush, the Nanaya menu is not slap-your-face extraordinary, comprising about 20 small-plate standards like karaage (fried chicken, $6.50), okonomiyaki (savory cabbage pancake, $8) and pan-fried shishitos ($6.50); plus a few ramens ($12-$14) and sandwiches (katsu-style, with breaded cutlets, $8-$10). No, the face-slapping part comes when these creatively-composed kitchen classics are placed in front of you. First off: the miso soup ($3.50). Like any American whose Japanese food fluency is mainly limited to what we’ve found in neighborhood sushi joints, I was expecting a warming but indifferently seasoned cloud of miso broth, perhaps with a bit of tofu and wakame seaweed if I was lucky. Instead, I got a stew loaded with onions, potato, carrots and other vegetables, with the onions in particular giving the soy-based broth a rich, almost French-onion-soup quality. Shockingly scrumptious. Next up: the gyukatsu sandwich ($10). Again, my expectations were exceeded in embarrassing fashion. Instead of a meek, pounded beef cutlet – which is only kind of katsu I’ve ever tasted – this one was excitingly thick and juicy, cooked to a perfect medium rare. More like an expertly prepared tri-tip than a cutlet, sheathed in a panko breading and wedged between two slices of Japanese milk bread, which were just as gloriously supple as they sound. Served with a tasty side of tangy tankatsu sauce, it’s a remarkable sandwich, and a remarkable deal at 10 bucks.

Though sushi was not available during my visit, Chow and Nakasu are working a limited menu of nigiri and rolls, according to my server. Unfortunately, my expectations are now pretty high, so if the fish isn’t at least a little revelatory, I’ll feel let down. Such is the burden of excellence.

According to the same staffer, the original plan was to keep this Arcade Lite location running on a limited basis until the Old Town Scottsdale space is ready – but the tavern has proven so popular with the local crowd, they’re considering keeping it. I hope so. This early visit suggests an unusual, almost mystical fixation on craft, and many secrets yet revealed. It’s perfect where it is.

For more than 50 years, PHOENIX magazine's experienced writers, editors, and designers have captured all sides of the Valley with award-winning and insightful writing, and groundbreaking report and design. Our expository features, narratives, profiles, and investigative features keep our 385,000 readers in touch with the Valley's latest trends, events, personalities and places.