Off to the Races

Written by Craig Outhier Category: Hot Topics Issue: November 2012
Group Free
Pin It

Bone up on the Valley’s hottest political bouts with this handy Election Day handicapper.

Total Arizona Registered Voters: 3,100,575

Republican: 1,113,123 (35.9%)

Democrat: 935,098 (30.16%)

Independent: 1,025,634 (33.08%)

THE FIGHT DOCTOR: Valley political consultant Dr. Michael O’Neil (O’Neil Associates)

Will Sheriff Joe meet his Waterloo? Or will the 80-year-old lawman survive his toughest challenge yet?

phm1112 pfja mdphm1112 pfpp md
Illustrations by Nicole Roegner

Joe Arpaio
HEIGHT: Five-time elected incumbent; law enforcement superstar
REACH: Get-off-my-lawn types; border enforcement advocates.
GLASS JAW?: Poor sex-crime arrest rate; “birther” hijinks

Paul Penzone
HEIGHT: Former Phoenix PD sergeant; director of Silent Witness protection program
REACH: Voters suffering from Sheriff Joe fatigue.
GLASS JAW?: Has about 1/100th of the name recognition of his opponent.

THE FIGHT  DOCTOR SAYS: Penzone is a credible candidate, but “any Sheriff Joe election is essentially a referendum on Sheriff Joe.”

A seasoned Mormon congressman and ex-Surgeon General vie for John Kyl’s seat.

phm1112 pfjf mdphm1112 pfrc md

Jeff Flake
HEIGHT: Six-term U.S. Congressman; former Goldwater honcho
REACH: Fiscal conservatives; East Valley homers
GLASS JAW?: Perceived “professional politician” stigma.

Richard Carmona
HEIGHT: Former U.S. Surgeon General (2002-2006); Purple Heart honoree
REACH: Hispanics and moderates; Tucson and Southern Arizona voters.
GLASS JAW?: He’s a Democrat. This is Arizona.

THE FIGHT  DOCTOR SAYS: Flake is the favorite, but “he suffered from $7 million of negative campaigning” by primary foe Will Cardon. Upset on the table.

Arizona’s other high-profile sheriff emerges from controversy to run for re-election.

phm1112 pfpb mdphm1112 pfkt md

Paul Babeu
HEIGHT: First Republican sheriff in Pinal County history
REACH: Border-protection minded Pinalians; statewide profile from “build the dang fence” ads.
GLASS JAW?: Scurrilous outing by gay ex-lover and half-naked self-portraits may
conceivably haunt him

Kevin Taylor
HEIGHT: One-time Ohio deputy; owns Mesa-based Taylor Made Security
REACH: May have greater appeal with Independents, the largest voting bloc in Pinal County.
GLASS JAW?: Never elected to office, he’s an unknown commodity... which might be an asset in this race.

THE FIGHT  DOCTOR SAYS: Look out for Independent candidate Ty Morgan, a 30-year PCSD officer.

Will the AZ GOP hold onto its super-majority in the senate and house? Watch this race.

phm1112 pfjl mdphm1112 pfea md

Jerry Lewis
HEIGHT: Current state senator; defeated Russell Pearce in a much-publicized 2011 recall election
REACH: Willingness to take on fellow Republican  Pearce bodes well in Democrat-majority Tempe.
GLASS JAW?: District 26 lies mostly outside his Mesa Mormon power-base.

Ed Ableser
HEIGHT: Currently serves in Arizona House of Representatives; pursuing Ph.D. in social work
REACH: “Progressive Mormon grad student” brand plays well to campus-area voters.
GLASS JAW?: Took guff for his call to formally apologize for CIA involvement in the 1973 coup in Chile.

THE FIGHT  DOCTOR SAYS: The GOP super-majority in the Senate is “history” if Lewis doesn’t pull an upset.

Two minority candidates duke it out in the Valley’s lone competitive congressional race.

phm1112 pfvp mdphm1112 pfks md

Vernon Parker
HEIGHT:  Special Assistant to President George H.W. Bush; Paradise Valley councilman
REACH: Well-heeled conservatives; would be first African-American congressman from Arizona.
GLASS JAW?: PV power-base mostly outside Tempe/Mesa/Scottsdale district boundaries.

Kyrsten Sinema
HEIGHT: Elected Arizona state senate (2010); law professor at ASU
REACH: The youth vote; would be first openly bisexual member of Congress.
GLASS JAW?: According to O’Neil, the GOP will “dredge up older [left wing] statements before she got circumspect with her verbage.”

THE FIGHT  DOCTOR SAYS: Dead even. “I get the sense this is a moderate district.”